Book club gift ideas that aren’t another bookmark

Updated October 17, 2026

Every book club eventually faces the gift question: a thank-you for the person who hosted all year, a holiday swap, a farewell for a member who is moving away. Bookmarks and mugs have been done. Here is a different idea, and how to make it work for a group.

The Book Club Night drawer

Our Book Club Night designs look like the evenings themselves: wine glasses beside dog-eared classics, candles on a crowded table, a novel face-down on the sofa mid-argument, a crime paperback and a plate of biscuits. They are illustrations without slogans, so they work for members who would never wear a “book club” T-shirt.

Midnight Margins phone case design — From the Book Club Night drawer.

Midnight Lit Circle phone case design — From the Book Club Night drawer.

For the host

Hosting means cleaning the house, finding enough chairs and pretending you finished the book too. A case for the host is a thank-you they will see every day. Pick a design from the evening they would recognise — the candlelit table of Midnight Lit Circle, or the comfortable chaos of Spine Debate.

For a gift swap

Every case is the same price — $24.99 — which makes swap budgets simple.
Ask members to put their phone model on their swap slip, or choose “not sure yet” in the gift finder and check later.
Returns are free within 30 days, so a wrong model or a design that misses is easy to fix.
If you are ordering several at once, each case ships separately to the address you enter at checkout.

For the friend who always picks the book

There is one member who reads everything first, annotates it, and arrives with tabs sticking out of every page. Margin Notes and Bookmark Ribbon were made for them.

Practical bits

Cases are dual-layer tough cases with raised edges around the screen and camera, made to order for iPhone 11 through 17, Galaxy S21 through S26 and Pixel 6 through 9. They ship within 48 business hours with free US shipping; delivery after that depends on the carrier. We don’t add notes to the package, so use the free reveal card to send a message with a picture of the design.

If the gift is for the holidays, we recommend ordering by December 14 for the best chance of US delivery by December 25.

Still choosing?

Three quick questions and the gift finder suggests designs that fit. Every case $24.99, free US shipping, free 30-day returns.

Open the gift finder All gift ideas

Questions

Can I order several cases at once?

Each checkout is one case to one address, so a swap is a few quick checkouts.

Do you offer group discounts?

Not at the moment — every case is $24.99 with free US shipping.

Can I return one if it doesn’t fit?

Yes, returns are free within 30 days.